Advice-Giving. The Ultimate Buzz Kill.

I think we all know this.  Unconsciously.  We’ve told our spouse how to load the dishwasher, our assistant how to set up the report, or (God forbid) told our teenage son how to drive a car. And there is there is the eye roll.  The exasperated sigh.  Once you start giving the how…all engines shut down.  Buzz. Kill.

If you think about it –  where is the engagement, the decision making, the buy in; the autonomy in someone else telling you how?  Dr. Srinivasan Pillay explains this in his book, Your Brain and Business. According to Dr. Pillay, “brain imaging shows that when advice is given, it “offloads” the value of the decision options from the listener’s brain, so that there are no correlations between brain activation and attributed value when advice is given, as compared to when it is not given…that is, advice turns the brain of the listener “off”.

Whoa.  I need to rethink my next road trip with my 17 year old at the wheel.  So if I tell him to “put both hands on the wheel” or “slow down”.  It is shutting his brain down.  Not a good thing when traveling down the freeway at 55 miles an hour.Buzz Kill 5

I am the same way.  I had a coach tell me what goal I was working on for the next two weeks and I felt myself slide back on my heels.  I didn’t lift a finger towards the goal; not a finger.

OK. So how do I stop giving unwanted, unsolicited, mind-shutting-down  advice?

These are the FOUR Not so Easy Steps:

1. Listen.  Isn’t this always the first step?  Is your spouse just really venting about the frustrations of the day?  Do they really just want some understanding? a comforting smile and nod? instead of you jumping in with a 25 step guide on how to fix their problem.

2. Ask.  Use open-ended questions like “what do you want to do?” or “what options do you have?”  Having the listener give you their ideas creates buy in and helps them brainstorm their own options.  Guess which idea will have the most weight? Yup, their idea.

3. Don’t Judge.  Unless they are asking for feedback…don’t jump in and start giving them all your wisdom.  If they ask for the feedback, give it constructively and sparingly.

4. Brainstorm.  If it’s going no where and the listener can’t seem to decide or is requesting your wisdom, ask for permission to brainstorm.  In brainstorming, there is no “how” or “wrong answer”.  Just throw out some off the wall ideas and see if the listener can glean their own answer or muddle their own idea from piecing together different ideas.  Making them their own.  Don’t take the lead. Or there will be no buy in, no finger lifting.

Doesn’t this make you wonder why “Dear Abby” was so popular for so many years?  Did anyone ever really take her advice?  Was the column there just for all of us armchair advice givers to live vicariously through Abby?

So I have to say, I try to keep my mouth shut when my son is driving.  Instead of advice, I say, “I got snagged for going 15 over the speed limit here.  Did you know those tickets are over $200?”  I’m just telling a story.  Enlightening him on my experience.  It’s not easy but I must say it’s a much less frustrating experience and he usually slows down.  Keep your advice to yourself.

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.